| 1 | Come Fly with Me | ♡ | 3:06 | Sammy Cahn / Jimmy Van Heusen / Don Sebesky | Steve Tyrell / Lew Soloff |
| 2 | It’s Magic | ♡ | 4:41 | Sammy Cahn / Jule Styne / Alan Broadbent | Steve Tyrell / David Mann |
| 3 | The Tender Trap | ♡ | 3:34 | Sammy Cahn / Jimmy Van Heusen / Alan Broadbent / Don Costa | |
| 4 | All the Way | ♡ | 3:42 | Sammy Cahn / Jimmy Van Heusen / Alan Broadbent | |
| 5 | Teach Me Tonight | ♡ | 3:32 | Sammy Cahn / Gene de Paul / Alan Broadbent | |
| 6 | The Second Time Around | ♡ | 4:21 | Sammy Cahn / Jimmy Van Heusen / Alan Broadbent | Steve Tyrell / David Mann |
| 7 | It’s Crazy | ♡ | 3:52 | Sammy Cahn / Artie Butler / Jimmy Van Heusen / Bob Mann | Steve Tyrell / Lew Soloff |
| 8 | Call Me Irresponsible | ♡ | 4:39 | Sammy Cahn / Jimmy Van Heusen / Alan Broadbent / Nelson Riddle | Steve Tyrell / David Mann |
| 9 | Ain’t That a Kick in the Head | ♡ | 2:18 | Sammy Cahn / Jimmy Van Heusen / Don Sebesky | Steve Tyrell / Lew Soloff |
| 10 | I Guess I’ll Hang My Tears Out to Dry | ♡ | 5:02 | Sammy Cahn / Jule Styne / Alan Broadbent | Steve Tyrell / Lawrence Feldman / Charlie Bisharat |
| 11 | It’s Been a Long, Long Time | ♡ | 3:10 | Sammy Cahn / Jule Styne / Alan Broadbent | Steve Tyrell / David Mann |
| 12 | Saturday Night (Is the Loneliest Night of the Week) | ♡ | 2:12 | Sammy Cahn / Jule Styne / John Oddo / Heinie Beau | Steve Tyrell / David Mann |
| 13 | I Fall in Love Too Easily | ♡ | 3:07 | Sammy Cahn / Jule Styne / Bob Mann | Steve Tyrell / Lew Soloff |
