| 1 | Santa Claus Is Coming to Town | ♡ | 4:21 | J. Fred Coots / Haven Gillespie | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 2 | Waiting for You at Christmas Time | ♡ | 3:31 | Jeannie Hoffman | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 3 | Bach Minuet | ♡ | 2:29 | Johann Sebastian Bach / Traditional | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 4 | Glory Halleluia | ♡ | 5:42 | Mississippi Fred McDowell / Traditional | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 5 | O Come All Ye Faithful | ♡ | 2:21 | John Francis Wade / Frederick Oakeley | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 6 | It’s Christmas Time Again | ♡ | 3:01 | Jack Elliott / Jeannie Hoffman / Jim Harwood / Sonny Burke / James K. Harwood / John Elliot | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 7 | Silent Night | ♡ | 3:12 | Josef Mohr / Franz Xaver Gruber | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 8 | Christopher Robin Is Saying His Prayers | ♡ | 2:40 | Claire Simson / A.A. Milne | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 9 | The Little Drummer Boy | ♡ | 5:07 | Harry Simeone / Katherine K. Davis / Henry Onorati | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 10 | O Holy Night | ♡ | 4:15 | Adolphe Adam / John Sullivan Dwight | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 11 | Sentimental ‘Round Christmas | ♡ | 3:40 | Jeannie Hoffman | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 12 | Joy to the World | ♡ | 2:04 | Traditional / Lowell Mason / Isaac Watts | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 13 | Heirlooms | ♡ | 4:33 | Brown Bannister / Bob Farrell / Amy Grant | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 14 | Bach and Us | ♡ | 2:55 | Traditional | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
| 15 | What Child Is This? | ♡ | 4:16 | Traditional / William Chatterton Dix | David Friesen / Jeannie Hoffman |
