| 1 | Deck the Halls | ♡ | 2:46 | Traditional / Thomas Oliphant / Ben Bram / Pentatonix | |
| 2 | Carol of the Bells | ♡ | 3:16 | Mykola Leontovych / Peter J. Wilhousky | |
| 3 | God Only Knows | ♡ | 2:49 | Tony Asher / Brian Wilson / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | |
| 4 | Hallelujah | ♡ | 4:29 | Leonard Cohen | |
| 5 | Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy | ♡ | 2:07 | Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | |
| 6 | Mary, Did You Know? | ♡ | 3:23 | Mark Lowry / Buddy Greene / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | |
| 7 | Joyful, Joyful | ♡ | 3:54 | Vin Rock / Ludwig van Beethoven / Ryan Toby / Andre Harris / Berry Gordy / Deke Richards / Kay Gee / Treach / Freddie Perren / Fonce Mizell / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | Pentatonix / Jazmine Sullivan |
| 8 | Do You Hear What I Hear? | ♡ | 3:34 | Gloria Shayne Baker / Noël Regney / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | Pentatonix / Whitney Houston |
| 9 | Little Drummer Boy | ♡ | 4:13 | Katherine K. Davis / Harry Simeone / Henry Onorati | |
| 10 | God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen | ♡ | 2:30 | Traditional / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | Pentatonix / Tori Kelly |
| 11 | Winter Wonderland/Don’t Worry Be Happy | ♡ | 3:28 | Steve Sidwell / Bobby McFerrin / Felix Bernard / Richard B. Smith / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | Pentatonix / Tori Kelly |
| 12 | White Winter Hymnal (Fleet Foxes Cover) | ♡ | 2:48 | Robin Pecknold / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | |
| 13 | Grown-Up Christmas List | ♡ | 4:43 | David Foster / Linda Thompson / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | Pentatonix / Kelly Clarkson |
| 14 | You’re a Mean One, Mr. Grinch | ♡ | 3:00 | Albert Hague / Dr. Seuss / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | |
| 15 | When You Believe | ♡ | 3:53 | Stephen Schwartz / Hans Zimmer / Pentatonix / Ben Bram / Maren Morris | Pentatonix / Maren Morris |
| 16 | Here Comes Santa Claus | ♡ | 2:37 | Harriett Melka / Gene Autry / Oakley Haldeman / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | |
| 17 | How Great Thou Art | ♡ | 4:10 | Carl Gustav Boberg / Stuart K. Hine | Pentatonix / Jennifer Hudson |
| 18 | That’s Christmas to Me | ♡ | 3:04 | Penny Lea Clark / Katy Lou Clark / Pentatonix / Ben Bram | |
| 19 | Coldest Winter [Bobby Alt Drum Mix] | ♡ | 2:29 | Ye / No I.D. / Roland Orzabal / Pentatonix / Ben Bram / Bobby Alt | |
