| 1 | Whisper Not/Love Me or Leave Me | ♡ | 4:18 | Gus Kahn / Walter Donaldson / Benny Golson / Leonard Feather | Mel Tormé / George Shearing |
| 2 | Out of This World | ♡ | 5:20 | Harold Arlen / Johnny Mercer | Mel Tormé / George Shearing |
| 3 | Someday I’ll Find You | ♡ | 2:43 | Noël Coward | Mel Tormé / George Shearing / John Leitham |
| 4 | The Midnight Sun | ♡ | 6:22 | Lionel Hampton / Johnny Mercer / Sonny Burke | Mel Tormé / George Shearing |
| 5 | New York, New York Medley: For Me and My Gal/Mack the Knife/Birth … | ♡ | 5:16 | Bertolt Brecht / Hal David / Lew Brown / Buddy DeSylva / Nancy Hamilton / Fred Ebb / E. Ray Goetz / Edgar Leslie / Kurt Weill / Henry Mancini / Ray Henderson / Morgan Lewis / John Kander / George W. Meyer / Marc Blitzstein / Stephen Ballantine | Mel Tormé / George Shearing |
| 6 | Folks Who Live on the Hill | ♡ | 5:17 | Jerome Kern / Oscar Hammerstein II | Mel Tormé / George Shearing |
| 7 | Bittersweet | ♡ | 5:40 | Sam Jones | Mel Tormé / George Shearing / John Leitham |
| 8 | Since I Fell for You | ♡ | 4:41 | Buddy Johnson | Mel Tormé / George Shearing |
| 9 | The Way You Look Tonight | ♡ | 3:57 | Jerome Kern / Dorothy Fields | Mel Tormé / George Shearing |
| 10 | Anyone Can Whistle/A Tune for Humming | ♡ | 5:34 | Stephen Sondheim | Mel Tormé / George Shearing |
| 11 | When Sunny Gets Blue | ♡ | 3:33 | Marvin Fisher / Jack Segal | Mel Tormé / George Shearing |
| 12 | Little Man, You’ve Had a Busy Day | ♡ | 5:55 | Al Hoffman / Maurice Sigler / Mabel Wayne | Mel Tormé / George Shearing |
