| 1 | O Holy Night | ♡ | 1:48 | Adolphe Adam / John Sullivan Dwight / Ralph Carmichael / Grace Price / Robert Black | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 2 | It Came Upon a Midnight Clear | ♡ | 3:20 | Richard Storrs Willis / Edmund Sears / Ralph Carmichael / Grace Price / Robert Black | Ella Fitzgerald / Robert Norberg / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 3 | Hark! The Herald Angels Sing | ♡ | 1:49 | Felix Mendelssohn / George Whitefield / Charles Wesley / William H. Cummings / Ralph Carmichael / Grace Price / Robert Black | Ella Fitzgerald / Robert Norberg / Ralph Carmichael / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 4 | Away in a Manger | ♡ | 2:13 | Ralph Carmichael / Robert Black / Grace Price / William James Kirkpatrick / Traditional / James Ramsey Murray / Frank Luther / Anonymous / Charles Hutchinson Gabriel | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 5 | Joy to the World | ♡ | 1:40 | George Frideric Handel / Isaac Watts / Lowell Mason / Ralph Carmichael / Robert Black / Grace Price | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 6 | The First Noël | ♡ | 1:50 | Davies Gilbert / John Stainer / Ralph Carmichael / Robert Black / Grace Price / Traditional | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 7 | Silent Night | ♡ | 2:51 | Franz Xaver Gruber / Josef Mohr / Ralph Carmichael / Grace Price / Robert Black | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 8 | O Come All Ye Faithful | ♡ | 2:45 | John Francis Wade / Ralph Carmichael / Grace Price / Robert Black | Ella Fitzgerald / Robert Norberg / Ralph Carmichael / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 9 | Sleep, My Little Jesus | ♡ | 2:17 | Ralph Carmichael / Robert Black / Grace Price / Arthur Ernst Bergmann / Traditional | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 10 | Angels We Have Heard on High | ♡ | 1:46 | Traditional / Ralph Carmichael / Grace Price / Robert Black | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 11 | O Little Town of Bethlehem | ♡ | 2:10 | Phillips Brooks / Lewis Henry Redner / Ralph Carmichael / Grace Price / Robert Black | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 12 | We Three Kings | ♡ | 2:07 | John Henry Hopkins, Jr. / Ralph Carmichael / Robert Black / Grace Price | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 13 | God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen | ♡ | 1:27 | Traditional / Ralph Carmichael / Grace Price / Robert Black | Ella Fitzgerald / Robert Norberg / Ralph Carmichael / Ralph Carmichael & his Orchestra / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 14 | Abide With Me | ♡ | 3:16 | William Henry Monk / Henry Francis Lyte | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 15 | Just a Closer Walk With Thee | ♡ | 5:05 | Robert Black / Traditional / Grace Price | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 16 | The Old Rugged Cross | ♡ | 3:54 | George Bennard / Charles Hutchinson Gabriel | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 17 | Brighten the Corner Where You Are | ♡ | 2:36 | Charles Hutchinson Gabriel / Ina Duley Ogdon / Ralph Carmichael / Robert Black / Grace Price | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 18 | I Need Thee Every Hour | ♡ | 3:40 | Annie S. Hawks / Robert Lowry | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 19 | In the Garden | ♡ | 3:18 | Charles Austin Miles | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 20 | God Be With You Till We Meet Again | ♡ | 1:22 | William G. Tomer / Jeremiah Rankin / Robert Black / Grace Price | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 21 | God Will Take Care of You | ♡ | 3:32 | Walter Stillman Martin / Civilla Durfee Martin | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 22 | The Church in the Wildwood | ♡ | 3:04 | William S. Pitts / Robert Black / Grace Price | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 23 | Throw Out the Lifeline | ♡ | 3:15 | Edwin Smith Ufford | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 24 | I Shall Not Be Moved | ♡ | 2:47 | Traditional / Grace Price / Robert Black | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 25 | Let the Lower Lights Be Burning | ♡ | 2:50 | Philip Paul Bliss / Philip Bliss / Grace Price / Robert Black | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 26 | What a Friend We Have in Jesus | ♡ | 4:04 | Charles Crozat Converse / Joseph Medlicott Scriven / Robert Black / Grace Price | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
| 27 | Rock of Ages, Cleft for Me | ♡ | 2:00 | Charles Wesley / Reverend Augustus Montague Toplady / Thomas Hastings / Traditional / Robert Black / Grace Price | Ella Fitzgerald / Ralph Carmichael Orchestra & Chorus |
