| 1 | In Love in Vain | ♡ | 6:21 | Jerome Kern / Leo Robin | Eddie Higgins Quintet / Scott Hamilton / Ken Peplowski |
| 2 | You Leave Me Breathless | ♡ | 6:05 | Friedrich Hollaender / Ralph Freed | Eddie Higgins Quintet / Scott Hamilton / Ken Peplowski |
| 3 | A Handful of Stars | ♡ | 8:20 | Ted Shapiro / Jack Lawrence | Eddie Higgins Quintet / Scott Hamilton / Ken Peplowski |
| 4 | Come Rain or Come Shine | ♡ | 6:43 | Harold Arlen / Johnny Mercer | Eddie Higgins Quintet / Scott Hamilton / Ken Peplowski |
| 5 | April in Torino | ♡ | 6:14 | | Eddie Higgins Quintet / Scott Hamilton / Ken Peplowski |
| 6 | Night Has a Thousand Eyes | ♡ | 8:16 | Dottie Wayne / Ben Weisman / Marilyn Garrett | Eddie Higgins Quintet / Scott Hamilton / Ken Peplowski |
| 7 | Flamingo | ♡ | 5:40 | | Eddie Higgins Quintet / Scott Hamilton / Ken Peplowski |
| 8 | Breezin’ Along With the Breeze | ♡ | 6:01 | Seymour Simons / Haven Gillespie / Richard A. Whiting | Eddie Higgins Quintet / Scott Hamilton / Ken Peplowski |
| 9 | A Portrait of Jenny | ♡ | 7:18 | J. Russel Robinson / Gordon Burdge | Eddie Higgins Quintet / Scott Hamilton / Ken Peplowski |
| 10 | Softly as in a Morning Sunrise | ♡ | 5:29 | Sigmund Romberg / Frank Mandel / Oscar Hammerstein II | Eddie Higgins Quintet / Scott Hamilton / Ken Peplowski |
| 11 | All Too Soon | ♡ | 5:13 | Duke Ellington / Carl Sigman | Eddie Higgins Quintet / Scott Hamilton / Ken Peplowski |
