| 1 | Poor Butterfly | ♡ | 3:58 | John L. Golden / John Raymond Hubbell | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 2 | I’ve Got the World on a String | ♡ | 3:25 | Harold Arlen / Ted Koehler | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 3 | Misty | ♡ | 4:11 | Erroll Garner / Johnny Burke | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 4 | Wonder Why | ♡ | 2:46 | Nicholas Brodzsky / Sammy Cahn | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 5 | Send in the Clowns | ♡ | 3:51 | Stephen Sondheim | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 6 | Black Coffee | ♡ | 6:22 | Sonny Burke / Paul Francis Webster | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 7 | Tenderly | ♡ | 5:23 | Walter Gross / Jack Lawrence | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 8 | The Best Is Yet to Come | ♡ | 2:31 | Cy Coleman / Carolyn Leigh | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 9 | I Will Say Goodbye | ♡ | 2:39 | Marilyn Bergman / Alan Bergman / Michel Legrand | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 10 | The Lamp Is Low | ♡ | 3:02 | Mitchell Parish / Maurice Ravel / Bert Shefter / Peter de Rose | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 11 | It’s Magic | ♡ | 4:58 | Jule Styne / Sammy Cahn | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 12 | Dedicated to You | ♡ | 6:03 | Sammy Cahn / Saul Chaplin / Hy Zaret | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 13 | I’ll Be Seeing You | ♡ | 4:54 | Sammy Fain / Irving Kahal | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 14 | Sarah | ♡ | 3:50 | Carroll Coates | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 15 | If You Could See Me Now | ♡ | 5:00 | Tadd Dameron / Carl Sigman | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 16 | Wave | ♡ | 4:04 | Antônio Carlos Jobim | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 17 | Embraceable You | ♡ | 7:42 | Ira Gershwin / George Gershwin | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
| 18 | Sarah | ♡ | 3:37 | Carroll Coates | Carmen McRae / Shirley Horn |
